Home » Manuscript Editing Services » Manuscript Critique Services
Reading Time: 7 minutes
Manuscript Critique Services

Manuscript Critique Services

Manuscript critiques (or editorial assessments) are not a requirement for authors. However, the proposed findings (given at any time of the writing process) are invaluable for revisions.

What is a Manuscript Critique?

A manuscript critique is a comprehensive and unbiased analysis of your finished (or unfinished) book. The editor describes the strengths and weaknesses of your story, characters, and structure and offers suggestions about revising the material.

 

Although not a required (or official) editing step in the publishing world, authors should know they can obtain a manuscript critique at any time, especially if they feel stuck or experience writer’s block.

Must Have Information

Why Consider a Manuscript Critique?

There are advantages to having a manuscript critique. The editor’s advice helps the author focus on the overall story before diving into specific details (which is the focus of developmental editing).

 

The benefits of getting a manuscript critique include the following:

Assess the market viability of the story. An editor can help show which market will (or will not) accept the tale and offer recommendations on the elements they believe the author should include for greater acceptance.

 

Gain a fresh perspective. Editors approach each manuscript with an open mind and offer their opinions based on the information found in the story. Authors may consider an editor’s ideas seriously because the insight is new and something they might not have otherwise considered.

 

Impartial input from a third party. Receiving feedback from an editor is more helpful than that given by family or friends, as the editor is less likely to worry about trying to spare the author’s feelings due to a personal relationship. 

 

Manage pacing problems within the story. The pace of your narrative affects your readers’ attention and interest. Is the information you provide in each scene sufficient, too little, or too much? Do you have areas of wordy description and other places where details are scarce? Does the story appear slower than you would like, or does it move too quickly? What can you do to fix these issues? An editor helps to answer these questions.

 

Pinpoint weaknesses and strengths. An editor shows where the story lacks energy and where it shines. The editor’s advice helps stimulate new ideas and ways to continue (or expand) the story accordingly.

 

Understand the difference between show and tell. Showing readers something through creative descriptions and dialogue is much different than telling them what they should see (or feel). An editor guides an author to help balance this discrepancy within their manuscript.

Elements of Interest for a Manuscript Critique

Although each editor is different in how they approach a manuscript critique, the typical areas of concentration include:

Character development

Dialogue

Imagery

Narrative arc

Pace

Plot/Subplot development

Setting

Tension

Voice

Manuscript Critique Style Sheets

Editors include a style sheet (or record of editorial changes) for all phases of the editing process they complete. Everyone from the author to the proofreader obtains a copy to ensure each part of the manuscript stays consistent as it nears publication.

 

The information found on the style sheets will differ depending on the editing your manuscript receives. Atwood LLC evaluates the following areas for manuscript critiques:

  • Breakdown
  • Manuscript Premise
  • In-Line Commentary Notes
  • General Strengths
  • Areas for Further Improvement
  • Specific Manuscript Notes
    • Character Development
    • Characterization
    • Conflicts
    • Consistency
    • Dialogue
    • Diction
    • Genre
    • Narrative Structure
    • Pacing and Tension
    • Plot
    • Premise
    • Setting
    • Spelling, Punctuation, and Grammar
    • Worldbuilding
  • Marketability
  • Next Steps

 

NOTE: For more information on manuscript critiques, check out the blog post What is a Manuscript Critique?

Manuscript Critique Style Sheet

Powered By EmbedPress

What can you expect to receive when your editor returns the manuscript?

The author can expect to receive the following items from the editor:

 

Original manuscript. Editors never touch the original and always make a working copy, so the author can easily reference the suggested revisions.

 

Edited manuscript with in-line commentary. Comments, queries, and examples appear, and reference the style sheet if more information or explanation when needed.

 

Style Sheet. A full breakdown of the elements of interest and the suggested revisions.

 

Timeline. Among the best ways to “view” how the story plays out on a calendar level.

 

Letter of Transmittal. A brief explanation for (1) what the author is receiving, (2) how to use the style sheet, (3) how to use the timeline (if one is not already available), and (4) instructions on how to contact Atwood LLC for follow-up within four (4) weeks (if needed).

How It Works

Pricing & Plans

Choose your word count for an estimated price.

Two columns
Vertical
Horizontal
Manuscript Critique
Summary
Name Total
"{{getWooProductName}}" has been added to your cart
Have a promocode?
Promocode Hide Show
Are you looking for a quick Sample edit?

We are happy to complete a sample edit (up to 1,000 words) for your manuscript. Please select and upload your file; someone will return the edited information within 24 hours.

Each Package Includes

2-Hour Response Time

Availability Between 8-5 PST

Complementary 45-Minute Kickoff Meeting

Confidentiality & Professionalism

Dedicated US-Based Assistant

Transparent Billing 

Weekly Detailed Progress Report

Weekly Timesheet Report

100% Satisfaction Guaranteed

Illustration of a notebook and checkmark

Have Questions?

A graphic showing a little white man with question marks over his head

Email & Telephone

colleen_atwood@atwood-va-llc.com

(206) 856-3977

Atwood, LLC

2843 SW Nevada Street

Seattle, WA 98126

Optimized by Optimole
Skip to content
Verified by MonsterInsights